Homeowners Insurance in Winter Haven, Florida (2024)

Protecting your property with the right home insurance is essential for financial security and peace of mind. A policy shields you from unexpected occurrences so you don’t lose out on the things that matter most.

Use this guide to find the best homeowners insurance in Winter Park. 

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Winter Haven is about $2,981 annually on a $150,000 home, $5,398 on a $300,000 home, and $7,747 on a $450,000 home.

While Florida has the highest home insurance rates in the country, Winter Haven residents should be pleased to hear that average rates in Winter Haven come in about 12% below the state average. 

This is mainly attributable to the city’s inland location that shields it from the brunt of hurricane and tropical storm damage. Hurricanes and high property values are two of the main drivers of Florida’s lofty insurance rates.

The following table lists average premiums from nine providers in Winter Haven, so you know what to expect when looking for coverage.

The premiums displayed in this article were obtained by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. They represent the most recent rate filings from the state’s largest insurers and can be utilized as an average of what Floridians can expect to pay for homeowners insurance each year. The example premiums are based on a policy for a Florida masonry home with a $500 non-hurricane deductible, a 2% hurricane deductible and no claims in the past three years.

The cost of home insurance rises as home value increases. Homeowners insurance rates are often more closely tied to the replacement cost of a home rather than its market value. The replacement cost is the cost to rebuild the home in case of a total loss, while market value includes factors such as land value and location.

It’s important to understand that various factors influence property values and insurance rates. While a higher property value can contribute to higher replacement costs and, consequently, higher insurance rates, other factors, especially risk-related ones, play significant roles.

We break down the influence of two more factors, home age, and wind mitigation measures on homes in Winter Haven below, starting with how these factors are categorized by insurers during premium determination.

Now, let’s see those factors in action, starting with average premiums from several of the city’s top insurers on a $150,000 house.

Wind mitigation reduced average rates in Winter Haven on $150,000 homes by about 41% or nearly $1,700 annually. Wind mitigation features strengthen a building to better withstand wind damage caused by hurricanes, tornadoes, and tropical storms, which home insurance companies in Winter Haven like.

Newly constructed homes tended to have the lowest premiums. New houses often have cheaper home insurance rates than older homes because of their newer components and up-to-date construction methods. 

Homes with modern wiring, plumbing, and roofs are less likely to cause issues related to fire, water, and wind damage. Also, new homes are built to meet current building codes and safety standards, which aids with hurricane resistance in Florida. See more average premiums in Winter Haven below for $300,000 homes.

Wind mitigation continues to slash rates, in some cases bringing premiums below newly constructed homes. The final table lists premiums on $450,000 houses in Winter Haven.

According to our analysis, Tower Hill and Citizens have the cheapest homeowners insurance in Winter Haven. While these companies may be the cheapest on average, you may find differently when getting quotes due to the many factors affecting premiums.

Tower Hill is a regional insurance carrier founded in Gainesville, offering products in 16 states. Citizens differs from Tower Hill and the other providers listed above because it’s a not-for-profit insurer funded by the Florida state government. Originally designed to be a last resort option for Florida consumers, Citizens has outgrown its original design and is actively trying to offload policyholders, so keep this in mind when quoting.

Every policyholder is different, and rates vary by company, location, and more. You won’t know which provider has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Winter Haven for your situation until you shop around, which is why we encourage you to take your time and compare rates.

Regardless of which company provides your home insurance plan, the standard policy contains six coverage areas to protect your property, possessions, and liability.

Coverage A, commonly known as dwelling coverage, helps protect the structure of your main home. It protects elements from head to toe, like your roof, walls, plumbing, flooring, and foundation, from damage caused by a covered peril on your policy.

Coverage B, otherwise known as other structures coverage, provides coverage for the structures on your property that aren’t attached to your main dwelling. It may cover elements like your shed, fence, detached garage, pool, carport, and more if a covered peril damages them.

Coverage C, or personal property coverage, brings you peace of mind when it comes to all the items you store on your property. This coverage can be invoked to repair or replace items like your patio furniture, prized art pieces, swanky espresso machine, and much more should they be damaged by a covered peril or stolen.

Coverage D, or loss of use coverage, can help you and your family should your home be rendered unlivable by a covered peril on your policy. It can help you pay for basic necessities like food, temporary lodging, and gasoline.

Coverage E, also known as personal liability coverage, can help you cover medical expenses and legal fees should you be found liable for a guest’s injuries on your property or damage to someone else’s property. 

Coverage F, also referred to as medical payments coverage, can help you cover medical expenses if a guest suffers a minor injury, such as a fractured ankle or a broken tooth, on your property, regardless of who was at fault. 

Getting the best homeowners insurance in Winter Haven requires understanding your coverage needs. Since every policyholder varies, you need to know how plans work and what you need to be covered to find one that suits your needs. Then, you should shop around to find a good provider at an affordable price.

Ensure your policy limits cover you and your property sufficiently. Guarantee that your dwelling is accounted for properly and insured to at least 80% of its value, if not more. Make a home inventory to determine the precise amount of personal property coverage you need. Increase your liability limits beyond the minimum to cover all your assets. For most people, $300,000 to $500,000 will do.

Be aware of policy exclusions and limitations that could impact coverage. Recognize whether your policy provides replacement cost coverage (which covers the cost of replacing or repairing damaged items without deducting for depreciation) or actual cash value (which factors in depreciation). Replacement cost coverage typically results in higher policy limits.

Certain items are excluded from standard coverage, and you may need an endorsement or rider to capture specific coverage needs, such as protection for high-value art and jewelry or business materials stored at your home.

Shop around to compare rates, discounts, and endorsements to save money. Don’t settle for the first quote you get. Another company could have the coverage you need at a better price.

You can also compare customer service among carriers when shopping around. If quoting online, note which providers have better websites and user experiences.

While looking for the best protection, you might notice that home insurance policies don’t cover flood insurance. Floods are the most common and costly natural disaster in the country, and home insurers can’t afford to cover them in their policies, or else premiums in Florida would become even higher than they are.

Florida is especially prone to flooding due to low-lying terrain bisected by lakes and rivers throughout the state. And, both coasts can experience storm surges during hurricanes and tropical storms.

Winter Haven isn’t immune to flooding. Heavy rains from Hurricane Ian caused some flooding in 2022. Properties near the many lakes that run through the city are also at risk.

A separate flood insurance policy is the only way to protect your property from flooding financially. Don’t overlook the need for flood insurance in Winter Haven, and think about getting a policy today.

Many factors affect premiums. Insurance companies analyze these factors to determine the risk associated with insuring your home. The goal is to set premiums that accurately reflect the level of risk while being certain that the insurer can cover potential claims while remaining financially stable.

Some of the most important factors affecting Winter Haven home insurance rates are:

Companies examine many variables about your home to determine damage likelihood. Houses near the water or in high-crime neighborhoods may have higher premiums, while homes near fire stations can receive discounts.

Old roofs, siding, and other components can increase the chances of property damage and raise rates. Alternatively, security systems, deadbolt locks, and SMART home features can lower premiums.

The extent of coverage, deductibles, endorsements, and discounts will affect your rates. Higher limits or many endorsements will increase the cost of your insurance, while raising your deductible or qualifying for several discounts will lower rates.

Having a history of many home insurance claims with previous insurers will raise future premiums. Policyholders who have filed multiple claims in the past three to five years often pay higher rates since insurance companies are concerned they’ll file another claim.

Homeowners insurance isn’t legally mandated in Winter Haven. But, when you take out a mortgage to purchase a home, your lender will require you to carry home insurance.

Your lender is investing in your home just as you are. If it gets damaged or destroyed, the lender can ensure it won’t lose its money thanks to the home insurance plan. Lenders require you to carry coverage for the life of your loan. If you don’t, it can force place insurance coverage on you, which would cost you more money than if you maintained a policy on your own.

With so much to keep track of when getting homeowners insurance quotes in Winter Haven, it isn’t a bad idea to seek the help of an insurance professional for guidance. We’re Clovered, an independent, Florida-based insurance agency, and we want to help in any way we can.

As an independent agency, we aren’t tied to one insurance company. We’re on your side and can help you choose the best carrier for your needs. Use our online quoting tool to compare rates and find a policy in minutes.

Or, you can call one of our licensed agents at 833-255-4117 during business hours for a quote. You can also email us at [email protected] with any questions.