Homeowners Insurance in Fort Myers, Florida (2024)

The relaxed living of the city comes at a bit of a price, though, when you look at its homeowners insurance rates. The prime location on the Gulf of Mexico exposes the town to some severe weather, which doesn’t bode well for premiums. Let’s take a good look at the cost of homeowners insurance in Fort Myers.

Home insurance in Fort Myers costs on average $3,915 for a $150,000 house, $7,099 for a $300,000 house, and $10,183 for a $450,000 house.

Florida tends to have some of the highest homeowners insurance prices in the nation, and Fort Myers comes rates are just above the state average. Average premiums across all of Florida are $3,325 per year for a $150,000 house, $6,026 for a $300,000 house and $8,644 for a $450,000 house.

Initially, it looks like State Farm seems to be the cheapest insurer. But, it can be hard to capture all aspects of a premium’s price point with an average. Let’s break the costs down further. 

The premiums displayed in this article were obtained by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. They represent the most recent rate filings from the state’s largest insurers and can be utilized as an average of what Floridians can expect to pay for homeowners insurance each year. The example premiums are based on a policy for a Florida masonry home with a $500 non-hurricane deductible, a 2% hurricane deductible and no claims in the past three years.

Here are average rates for $150,000 homes accounting for home age and wind mitigation:

Fort Myers contains a few affluent communities. It would be harder now than ever to find a home worth $150,000, so you may need more coverage. Fort Myers insurance rates, although generally on the higher side, vary considerably when looking at $300,000 and $450,000 worth of coverage.

As you can see, insurance premiums on older homes in Fort Myers can climb into the tens of thousands of dollars. Wind mitigation is essential, especially if your house wasn’t built within the last two decades. 

On $300,000 houses built before 2001, premiums on homes with wind mitigation were $6,189 lower per year than those without.

Rates for $450,000 houses with wind mitigation built before 2001 were $8,912 lower than the same houses without wind mitigation.

Citizens Insurance is one of the largest providers in the state, and it’s usually among the most affordable. According to the numbers above, it has some of the cheapest average premiums in Fort Myers. 

After unprecedented hurricanes hit Florida in the late 1990s and early 2000s, many insurers were either bankrupted by the number of claims filed or stopped writing new policies afterward due to the increased risk.

To remedy the resulting insurance issue, the Florida government founded Citizens, a non-profit “insurer of last resort” to cover homes in Florida that would prove to be unreasonably expensive to insure or entirely uninsurable. Private companies didn’t want to take on the risk in Florida, so the state government had to create a new option.

While it’s generally more affordable, Citizens has its coverage limitations. Since it’s state-funded and state-managed, policyholders with Citizens are at the mercy of state regulations. For example, if the company has a deficit, Florida law requires Citizens to make up the money, usually through assessments or rate hikes. Also, homes above a certain value aren’t eligible to acquire Citizens Insurance. 

Nevertheless, Citizens is prevalent in Fort Myers because many homes in the city are especially susceptible to weather-related risks we’ll discuss in-depth a little later on.

Several factors other than wind mitigation come into effect when looking for a homeowners policy. These include:

The effects of these factors, as well as other small-scale contributors, can make determining the cost of a typical premium tricky. Additionally, for those looking to buy in Fort Myers, there are a few other region-specific concerns that affect premiums there:

A standard homeowners insurance policy doesn’t cover flooding. This could be a concern to Fort Myers residents considering many areas of the city are located in federally designated flood zones. Florida always receives a lot of rainfall, and just earlier this year, residents of southern Fort Myers reported nearly unprecedented levels of rain.

The Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA) creates flood maps for the United States that determine the flooding risk level of areas around the country. Much of the residential land along the Caloosahatchee River and areas around downtown Fort Myers are AE flood zones. Parts of southern Fort Myers are in AH flood zones.

At the time of writing in July of 2024, several areas of Lee County, including parts of Fort Myers Beach, are at risk of losing their FEMA flood insurance discounts. The decision hasn’t been finalized and could affect thousands of homeowners in the area who would lose their 25% discount on flood insurance.

Insurance costs more in high-risk areas. While a flood policy is optional with your home insurer, your mortgage lender might require you to get one if you live in an especially high-risk zone.

Yes, Fort Myers does experience sinkholes, but not very often. While Florida is the most sinkhole-prone state in the country, the northern and central parts of the state are where they’re most pervasive. The limestone under the earth that wears away and causes sinkholes isn’t as common under Fort Myers.

However, natural sinkholes are still a possibility and have happened in the area before. A standard homeowners policy doesn’t cover sinkholes. Earth movements are usually excluded in homeowners insurance because it focuses on the physical structures of a property. A physical structure can be given a replacement cost and insured for that amount. It would be difficult to assess the monetary value of land under someone’s house.

If your property is damaged by a sinkhole, it’s likely not covered unless you purchase optional sinkhole coverage or the damage is very severe. Florida is one of only a few states that require insurers to cover “catastrophic ground cover collapse.” 

For an earth movement, like a sinkhole, to be considered catastrophic ground cover collapse and necessitate coverage from an insurance company, it has to meet certain strict criteria. This includes making the home unlivable and being ordered to evacuate the home.

Fort Myers sits on the west coast of Florida, touching the Gulf of Mexico. Hurricanes love the warm waters and temperatures of the Gulf, so residents of Fort Myers must always be wary of hurricanes come hurricane season, like Hurricane Irma in 2017.

Homeowners insurance covers hurricane damage, but it comes at a bit of a price in Florida. The mere danger of severe weather hikes up premium prices, and homeowners must also pay a hurricane deductible, which is different than a standard homeowners insurance deductible when filing a hurricane damage claim.

A hurricane deductible is usually more costly since it’s typically based on a percentage of dwelling coverage. But, if you have to file multiple claims because your home was damaged more than once in a season, you only have to pay the hurricane deductible once.

Wind mitigation can help mightily in reducing rates. While there’s an upfront cost, the savings you’d experience in the long-term will likely make wind mitigation a worthy investment. This could involve updating your roof, windows and doors; to know where to start, you should have a wind mitigation inspection done by a certified inspector on your home.

Another way to save money is by comparing rates. Finding a plan that covers you at the right price can seem daunting, but Clovered tries to make it as intuitive as possible. Clovered’s online quote engine allows you to build an insurance policy that fits your life and compare the cost of this plan from several top providers. Clovered was built to help people make good decisions about insurance quickly and efficiently.