Homeowners Insurance in Rochester, New York

  • Homeowner
  • /
  • Homeowners Insurance in Rochester, New York

Rochester in western New York lies between Lake Ontario and the Finger Lakes, helping make the state’s fourth largest city an attractive destination. Rochester residents need the right insurance coverage to protect their properties. 

Homeowners insurance will financially guard you from several possible types of damage. Subpar coverage jeopardizes your house, family, and finances from uncontrollable events, so it’s worth taking the time to find the best coverage.

We break down average rates, cost factors, and more below to help you find the best home insurance in Rochester.

How Much Is Homeowners Insurance in Rochester, New York?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Rochester is about $1,078 annually, which is lower than the state average of $1,489 per year.

New York generally ranks middle-of-the-pack or lower for home insurance rates nationwide. Coverage is generally affordable in the state, especially if you’re outside New York City, as is the case in Rochester, where residents don’t need to worry about hurricane or flood damage as much as those in coastal cities do.

Homeowners insurance rates vary by location because different places have different likelihoods of property damage, accounting for factors like natural disaster susceptibility and crime rates. Also, local property values influence premiums.

Look at the following table for average home insurance rates in Rochester based on home value.

Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in Rochester
Dwelling Coverage $200,000 $300,000 $400,000
Annual Premium $910 $1,364 $1,819

A primary factor in home insurance premiums is your home’s replacement cost, which is the amount to rebuild the house back to its original condition after property damage. Larger, nicer homes have higher replacement costs. So, insurance premiums rise as home value increases.

Insurers examine many more variables to determine rates, and every company has a slightly different way of calculating their premiums.

Cheapest Homeowners Insurance Companies in Rochester, New York

State Farm had the cheapest homeowners insurance in Rochester of the companies we examined. However, you might find differently once you get quotes of your own, as these averages don’t reflect the possible intricacies of your property or policy.

Average Rates of Homeowners Insurance Companies in Rochester
Company Average Annual Rate
Travelers $892
State Farm $824
Nationwide $946
Allstate $1,156
Farmers $1,958
Average $1,078

We examined five well-known national carriers, but these are far from the only home insurance companies in Rochester. It’s a good idea to compare premiums from these large companies with smaller, regional insurers, too. 

It’s essential to always shop around and compare home insurance rates in Rochester from more than one company to find the cheapest coverage. You won’t know if you’re getting the best deal until you compare the premiums offered among carriers.

What Does Rochester Homeowners Insurance Cover?

While rates vary by company, the coverage you receive in a home insurance plan always remains constant. All HO3 insurance policies, the most common type of homeowners insurance, contain the same coverage areas for your property and liability, as outlined below.

Rochester Homeowners Insurance Coverages
Coverage Definition
Dwelling Coverage Dwelling coverage financially protects your home’s structure, including the roof, walls, flooring, patios, foundation, and more.
Other Structures Coverage Other structures coverage extends protection to features on your property not attached to your main house, such as fences, sheds, pools, and detached garages.
Personal Property Coverage Personal property coverage guards your possessions, including furniture, electronics, clothing, jewelry, tools, and more, from theft and damage.
Loss of Use Coverage Loss of use coverage helps cover living costs if you’re forced to move out of your home after it suffers significant damage. Your insurer can cover temporary lodging, food, and more.
Liability Coverage Liability coverage covers medical bills and legal fees if you’ve been found legally liable for someone’s injuries or property damage.
Medical Payments Coverage Medical payments coverage is designed for minor medical expenses if someone is hurt on your property, regardless of fault.

How to Get the Best Homeowners Insurance in Rochester

The best homeowners insurance in Rochester will cover your belongings, property, and liability at an affordable price. It’s difficult to recommend an outright best company because every policyholder differs. So, the company with the best price, discounts, and coverage options for you might not be the best for someone else.

You’ll probably need to customize the coverage in your plan to tailor it to your circumstances, which could involve adjusting your policy limits, considering endorsements, and raising your deductible.

Alter Coverage Limits

Every coverage area has a maximum possible payout called a coverage limit. You can change your coverage limits to suit your needs.

For example, you can set your dwelling limit between 80% to 100% of your home’s replacement cost, which adjusts your reimbursement after property damage. You can also change your liability limits. We typically recommend between $300,00 and $500,000 in liability coverage for most people, but you can increase your limits up to $1 million if needed. Raising your liability limits is relatively cheap, and it’s better to be safe than sorry.

Consider Endorsements

You can also enhance your coverage in your plan beyond what’s included by default with an endorsement. Endorsements add coverage for certain items or risks that standard policies normally exclude.

For instance, a useful endorsement throughout New York is water backup coverage. Heavy rainfall combined with subpar drainage systems can lead to water backing up through your basement, even with a sump pump. Water backup coverage can help cover such scenarios, as water backing up through drains and pipes is excluded under default coverage.

Other common endorsements include home-based business protection, sinkhole coverage, and scheduled personal property coverage.

Adjust Your Deductible

Everyone wants to cut costs when it comes to their home insurance plan. Raising your deductible is an easy way to lower your insurance premiums without sacrificing much in coverage.

Your home insurance deductible is the amount of money you must pay when filing a claim before your insurer steps in to cover the rest of the damage bill. A deductible prevents policyholders from filing claims for every little minor incident. Technically, property damage must exceed your deductible for it to be eligible for coverage from your provider.

Common deductibles range from $250 to $5,000. You choose your deductible when quoting. Selecting a higher deductible lowers the chances of your insurer covering your claim, which reduces your risk and lowers your monthly premiums.

What to Know About Flood Insurance in Rochester

While shopping for coverage, you’ll notice that even the best home insurance policies won’t cover flooding. Flood damage is normally excluded from all homeowners insurance plans, which is important to realize because floods are more common than you might think.

Floods are the most common natural disaster in the country, causing over $5 billion in damage annually. Anywhere it can rain, it can flood. While Rochester doesn’t have many federally designated flood zones, heavy rainfall in short periods has caused issues in the past.

You may want to consider flood insurance in Rochester to fully protect your home and personal property from Mother Nature. Most people get plans through the National Flood Insurance Program, but you can also shop around from private flood insurance carriers.

Rochester Home Insurance Cost Factors

The average home insurance in Rochester costs about $1,078 annually. Several factors affect rates. Companies examine factors about your house to assess your likelihood of property damage. They also consider coverages and other details you opt for in your policy that can increase your amount of insurance, thus changing the cost of your plan.

Property Details

Carriers note your location to determine your likelihood of suffering certain property damage, like floods or thefts. Houses in areas of high crime or frequent home insurance claims will have higher premiums.

Additionally, companies will note your home’s age, size, and construction details. Larger houses cost more to rebuild and more to insure. Older houses, with their worn components and dated construction, are more likely to suffer property damage and often have higher premiums. Carriers may ask about the age of home components like your roof and appliances.

Certain features in and around your home can also influence your premiums. Companies ask about attractive nuisances, such as trampolines and playground equipment. Having these items increases your liability risk and often raises rates. Conversely, having a security system can lower your rates.

Policy Details

Details of your policy also affect your rates of property insurance in Rochester. Opting for endorsements and higher coverage limits will raise your premiums. On the other hand, qualifying for discounts will lower premiums. Raising your deductible is also a quick way to reduce your insurance costs.

Is Home Insurance Required in Rochester?

Homeowners insurance in Rochester isn’t required by law. However, many homeowners are still required to have coverage by their mortgage lenders.

When lenders give you a mortgage, they put down significant amounts of money to help you purchase the house. Your home is an investment to a lender, and they hope to eventually make money on the purchase just as you do.

To protect their investment, lenders require homeowners insurance as part of their home loans. This way, if the home gets destroyed by an uncontrollable event, such as a fire, the lender can recoup the money they put into the house from the insurance company.

How to Get Home Insurance Quotes in Rochester, New York

Although you wish it was impervious to damage, your home is never fully safe from what life can throw at it, from fires to theft to wind and hail. You need the right homeowners insurance to protect your property and give you peace of mind. Our team at Clovered can help you find the perfect coverage. 

Compare your options online with our quoting engine. All you must do is provide some information about yourself and your property, and you’ll see plans from some of the top providers in New York state.

If you prefer the help of an expert, you can always call our licensed agents at 833-255-4117 during business hours, and we’d be happy to help you with your Rochester homeowners insurance quotes. You can also email us with questions at agent@clovered.com.

Finding the Right Insurance Brokers in Rochester, New York

Comparing rates from multiple providers is crucial to finding the best price on home insurance in Yonkers. If you want help shopping for quotes, you can turn to an insurance broker or agent. Both have their advantages.

An insurance agency in Rochester can be captive or independent. Captive agents work for one carrier and will work with you to secure coverage from that provider. Independent insurance agents in Rochester partner with several companies and can use your information to find the best option for you.

Unlike an agent, even an independent agent, who works for or is contracted with insurance companies, brokers represent only you. Insurance brokers in Rochester can use your information and gather quotes for you to find the best coverage. 

Whether you use a broker or an agency, it’s always best to shop around for home insurance when looking for coverage. Comparing rates from multiple carriers is the best way to save money and find the best policy for your needs. 

One advantage of using an agency like ours at Clovered is our online quoting tool. As mentioned previously, we can help you compare your options and bind coverage entirely online. We will also help you handle claims and other policy servicing needs if needed. We’re always here for you.

It's Time to Switch Your Homeowners Insurance

We partner with the nation's top homeowners insurance companies so you can get a custom policy at an affordable price.

The editorial content on Clovered’s website is meant to be informational material and should not be considered legal advice.

Scroll back to Top