Homeowners Insurance in Cutler Bay, Florida

  • Homeowner
  • /
  • Homeowners Insurance in Cutler Bay, Florida

Hurricane Andrew left the town of Cutler Bay, a southern suburb of Miami, in pieces in 1992, underlining the importance of having homeowners insurance.

While beachside living has many perks, you can’t overlook the threat of property damage from various potential causes. Unfortunately, finding adequate coverage at an affordable price in Florida is easier said than done.

We want to help residents find cheap home insurance in Cutler Bay. Read on to learn helpful tips and information on finding the right provider and policy.

How Much Is Homeowners Insurance in Cutler Bay, Florida?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Cutler Bay is about $8,173 annually on a $150,000 home, $14,617 on a $300,000 home, and $21,066 on a $450,000 home.

South Florida has very expensive insurance premiums because of the area’s susceptibility to hurricanes and generally high property values. Florida already has some of the highest rates in the country overall, so South Florida and Cutler Bay residents especially feel the brunt of this financial burden.

Other than Monroe County, Miami-Dade County has the state’s most costly average home insurance rates.

The table below contains average premiums from some top home insurance companies in Cutler Bay. 

Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in Cutler Bay
Company $150,000 House $300,000 House $450,000 House
Allstate $3,918 $7,008 $10,100
Citizens $4,513 $8,054 $11,600
Florida Penn $8,418 $15,048 $21,685
Liberty Mutual $4,303 $7,680 $11,061
People’s Trust $15,132 $27,087 $39,052
Southern Oak $13,046 $23,349 $33,661
State Farm $5,669 $10,147 $14,629
Stillwater $4,366 $7,810 $11,257
Universal Property $10,524 $18,840 $27,163
Average $8,173 $14,617 $21,066
It’s Time to Switch Your Homeowners Insurance

We partner with the nation’s top homeowners insurance companies so you can get a custom policy at an affordable price.

While rates vary by company, you’ll notice that average premiums always rise as home value increases. This trend occurs because insurers base the amount of coverage you need on your home’s replacement cost. Replacement cost is the amount of money required to return your home to its pre-loss condition after damage based on construction and labor expenses.

Larger, nicer homes always cost more to insure. When we reference home value in this article, note that we mean replacement cost. It’s distinct from your home’s market value, which is determined by market real estate factors and location.

The tables below list home insurance rates in Cutler Bay for homes at the three different price levels noted above while accounting for two other critical factors that affect premiums: home age and wind mitigation.

Cost of Homeowners Insurance on $150,000 House in Cutler Bay
Company Pre-2001 No Wind Pre-2001 w/Wind 2001-Present
Allstate $6,309 $2,829 $2,617
Citizens $6,177 $3,346 $4,016
Florida Penn $12,501 $6,678 $6,076
Liberty Mutual $6,008 $3,083 $3,819
People’s Trust $29,600 $7,084 $8,711
Southern Oak $20,409 $11,007 $7,721
State Farm $9,220 $4,480 $3,307
Stillwater $6,267 $4,000 $2,830
Universal Property $19,800 $5,764 $6,009
Average $13,207 $5,808 $5,504

The premiums displayed in this article were obtained by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation. They represent the most recent rate filings from the state’s largest insurers and can be utilized as an average of what Floridians can expect to pay for homeowners insurance each year. The example premiums are based on a policy for a Florida masonry home with a $500 non-hurricane deductible, a 2% hurricane deductible and no claims in the past three years.

Florida Office of Insurance Regulation Premium Consideration Factors
Home Construction Coverage Definition
*Wind Mitigation Any protection on your home that helps decrease the damage caused by strong winds like a hurricane. This can include certain roof attachments and coverings, extra water-resistant seals and impact-resistant doors and windows.
Pre-2001 Construction w/ No Wind Mitigation These premiums represent homes built before 2001 with no wind mitigation features.
Pre-2001 Construction w/ Wind Mitigation These premiums represent homes built before 2001 with maximum wind mitigation features.
2001-Present Construction These premiums represent homes with limited wind mitigation features and no hip roof built from 2001, when Florida redesigned its building codes and mandated that new construction withstand hurricane-force winds better. 

Wind mitigation is a critical factor in homeowners insurance rates in Florida. Given the state’s vulnerability to hurricanes and tropical storms, insurance companies closely assess the level of wind mitigation measures in place when determining premiums. Homes equipped with hurricane-resistant features are eligible for discounts.

On average, wind mitigation reduced premiums on older houses in Cutler Bay by about 56% or about $7,000 per year.

Look at premiums on $300,000 homes in the next table.

Cost of Homeowners Insurance on $300,000 House in Cutler Bay
Company Pre-2001 No Wind Pre-2001 w/Wind 2001-Present
Allstate $11,356 $5,092 $4,575
Citizens $11,119 $6,023 $7,021
Florida Penn $22,502 $12,020 $10,623
Liberty Mutual $10,814 $5,549 $6,676
People’s Trust $53,280 $12,751 $15,229
Southern Oak $36,736 $19,813 $13,498
State Farm $16,596 $8,064 $5,781
Stillwater $11,281 $7,200 $4,948
Universal Property $36,640 $10,375 $10,506
Average $23,772 $10,455 $9,623

Older homes tend to have more wear and tear on their structural components and systems, making them more susceptible to damage. As a result, insurance companies often charge higher premiums for older homes, as the tables show. 

With no wind mitigation, average rates on old, expensive homes in South Florida get out of hand. However, such costly houses usually have some wind mitigation installed at some point, so it’s relatively rare to find someone paying that much. Also, if you received that quote, you likely just wouldn’t pick that policy. 

The final table lists rates for $450,000 homes in Cutler Bay.

Cost of Homeowners Insurance on $450,000 House in Cutler Bay
Company Pre-2001 No Wind Pre-2001 w/Wind 2001-Present
Allstate $16,403 $7,355 $6,542
Citizens $16,060 $8,700 $10,040
Florida Penn $32,503 $17,363 $15,191
Liberty Mutual $15,621 $8,016 $9,547
People’s Trust $76,960 $18,418 $21,777
Southern Oak $53,063 $28,618 $19,302
State Farm $23,972 $11,648 $8,267
Stillwater $16,294 $10,400 $7,076
Universal Property $51,480 $14,986 $15,024
Average $34,337 $15,101 $13,761

Again, no company expects you to pay $50,000 or more in premiums. This is just what a plan would cost, given their averages on other homes they cover.

It’s Time to Switch Your Homeowners Insurance

We partner with the nation’s top homeowners insurance companies so you can get a custom policy at an affordable price.

Companies With the Cheapest Homeowners Insurance in Cutler Bay

According to our findings, Allstate and Stillwater had the cheapest homeowners insurance in Cutler Bay. While this is useful to know, keep in mind that these rates are averages, and you may experience a more affordable rate elsewhere once you get quotes.

While Allstate is the more well-known of the two, both companies are national carriers offering their products in all 50 states. Large providers can sometimes offer more affordable rates because they can spread their financial risk among their many customers and aren’t over-exposed to threats in one area.

However, you shouldn’t discount smaller regional companies entirely. You’ll never truly know which carrier has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Cutler Bay for your circumstances until you get quotes. Rates vary based on location and property, so it’s hard to know your insurance cost before you get an exact quote.

Cutler Bay Homeowners Insurance Coverages

Home insurance policies typically include the same core coverages no matter which company provides the plan. Policies cover your property and belongings from several possible damage sources called perils, such as fires, hurricanes, and theft, and provide reimbursement when you’re affected by such perils. The coverages are as follows:

Cutler Bay Homeowners Insurance Coverages
Coverage Definition
Dwelling Coverage Dwelling coverage covers the physical structure of your home, including the roof, flooring, foundation, plumbing, air conditioner, and more.
Other Structures Coverage Other structures coverage protects fixtures on your property not attached to your main house, such as sheds, fences, detached garages, and pools.
Personal Property Coverage Personal property coverage financially guards your possessions, including furniture, electronics, clothing, jewelry, tools, bicycles, artwork, and more.
Loss of Use Coverage Loss of use coverage covers living expenses, such as gas and lodging, if you’re forced to move out of your house after covered property damage renders it uninhabitable.
Liability Coverage Liability coverage helps cover your finances if you’re found legally liable for someone’s injuries or property damage. Your insurer can cover medical bills, legal fees, and more.
Medical Payments Coverage Medical payments coverage is designed to cover minor medical bills resulting from injuries someone can suffer, regardless of fault.

How to Get the Best Home Insurance in Cutler Bay

The best homeowners insurance in Cutler Bay differs by person, as everyone has different properties and coverage needs. But, the best policy will always cover your property, belongings, and liability sufficiently. To achieve optimal protection, you should adjust your coverage limits and shop around to find the right carrier.

Tailor Your Policy

When getting quotes, you’re responsible for setting your policy limits. While the insurance provider often recommends limits to choose from, you can fine-tune your plan to cover your property precisely and save some money.

Make a home inventory to determine your personal property coverage limit. A home inventory is a catalog of all your possessions, including all prices. This record gives you an exact number to set your personal property limit, and it would be handy in a claim.

You can also raise or lower your liability limits depending on your financial assets, but we suggest opting for limits higher than the minimum to be safe. 

Adjusting your deductible in home insurance can significantly impact your policy’s cost and your out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim. A home insurance deductible is the initial amount of money a homeowner must pay out of pocket before their insurance company covers a claim.

Raising your deductible lowers insurance premiums since you’re agreeing to cover more up-front costs before filing a claim. Common deductibles range from $500 to $2,000.

Compare Options

Shop around to compare general rates, endorsements, and potential discounts. You may save more money through discounts at one company over another, for instance. Also, you can gauge which companies have better customer service when quoting with them.

Maintaining the best home insurance in Cutler Bay involves revisiting your policy periodically. You can raise or lower your coverage limits to increase protection or save money based on life changes. For example, you might need to increase your dwelling coverage limit if you renovate or add to your home.

What to Know About Flood Insurance in Cutler Bay, Florida

Home insurance policies typically never include protection from flooding, yet many homeowners don’t realize this until it’s too late. Flooding is the most common natural disaster in the country. Cutler Bay’s proximity to the ocean, drainage issues, and consistent rainfall make it particularly dangerous.

We recommend looking into flood insurance in Cutler Bay sooner rather than later. You can get a policy backed by the government from the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or look into the growing private flood insurance market.

Cutler Bay’s efforts to mitigate and prevent possible flood damage through the NFIP’s Community Rating System qualify residents for discounts of up to 35% on federally-backed flood insurance policies.

Stay Above Water With Flood Insurance

Do you want to pay for costly and common flood damage yourself or have an insurance policy pick up the tab?

Cost Factors of Home Insurance in Cutler Bay, Florida

Insurance companies analyze several aspects of policyholders to determine the risks associated with covering a certain person and their property. Financial risk essentially refers to the likelihood of your property generating a claim, which costs an insurer money. 

A riskier person and place will have higher premiums. Important factors affecting your property’s risk and rates  include:

Location: Homes in flood zones, high-crime areas, or on the waterfront may have higher premiums because they’re more likely to suffer damage. Waterfront homes often receive the brunt of wind and water damage in a hurricane.

Construction Materials: In addition to wind mitigation, the type of materials used to build your home can affect insurance rates. Masonry homes withstand winds and fires better and often have lower premiums than frame houses.

Home Construction: Wind mitigation features, roof type, and home condition affect insurance rates. Older or dilapidated homes usually have higher premiums.

Attractive Nuisances: Pools, trampolines, and playground equipment are known as attractive nuisances in the insurance industry. These features increase your liability risk and will often raise your premiums.

Dog Breeds: Owning certain historically aggressive dog breeds, such as rottweilers and pit bulls, can raise Cutler Bay home insurance rates at some insurers.

Claims History: Insurers will ask about your claims history. If you’ve filed several claims in the recent past, you’re typically seen as more of a financial risk than someone who has never filed a claim. A person or place that has generated several claims will likely experience higher rates.

Market Factors: The availability of insurance providers in your area can impact pricing. More competition can lead to more competitive rates. Also, company behavior and needs can dictate higher or lower premiums, like if a firm needs to raise rates to offset recent losses.

Is Home Insurance Required in Cutler Bay?

Homeowners insurance isn’t required in Cutler Bay by law, but mortgage lenders typically mandate their lendees to keep insurance plans. 

When lenders put money down with you to help you buy a house, they’re essentially investing in the property. To protect their financial input, they stipulate homeowners insurance as part of mortgage loans. So, if a fire, hurricane, or other disaster destroys the property, you and your lender can recoup your money through the insurance plan.

If you pay off your mortgage or purchase your property with cash, no entity will require you to keep home insurance. But, we still recommend it, especially in South Florida, as rebuilding after a possible disaster can be a nightmare if it all must come out of your own pocket.

How to Get Home Insurance Quotes in Cutler Bay

Comparing rates and quotes is the most critical part of getting home insurance. If you want assistance with the process, don’t hesitate to reach out to us at Clovered, a Fort Lauderdale-based independent insurance agency.

Call our licensed agents at 833-255-4117 during business hours. Our team is based in South Florida, so you’ll be speaking to fellow residents who know the difficulty of finding cheap coverage in the state.

You can also use our online quoting tool to compare rates and buy a policy online anytime. Feel free to email us at agent@clovered.com as well if you have any questions.

It's Time to Switch Your Homeowners Insurance

We partner with the nation's top homeowners insurance companies so you can get a custom policy at an affordable price.

The editorial content on Clovered’s website is meant to be informational material and should not be considered legal advice.

Scroll back to Top