Homeowners Insurance in Auburn, Alabama (2024)

Nestled amongst the towering Alabama whistling pines and boasting a bustling population of more than 75,000, Auburn is home to the infamous university of the same name and an abundance of outdoor activities for its full- and part-time residents who are lucky enough to call it home.

While many of the city’s residents are students earning degrees in a wide variety of studies, the vast majority are homeowners. They get to enjoy the rigors of football games in the fall, the Chewacla State Park in the spring and its many bodies of water, such as the Auburn City Lake, in the summer.

Auburn residents are in luck when it comes to homeowners insurance as well. Due to its geographical location and other varying factors, it shares the title of having some of the lowest homeowners rates in the nation. Let’s take a look at what you can expect to pay, what factors are at play in determining rates and much more.

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Auburn, Alabama is $1,537 per year. But your premiums depend heavily on the value of your house. Homeowners with a house valued at $150,000 can expect to pay $1,204 per year, while homeowners with a $300,000 house can expect to pay $1,870 per year.

The main differentiating factor in premium pricing is the home’s value. The more a house costs, the more it will cost to insure. But the value isn’t one-for-one, so premiums won’t double simply due to a house’s value doubling.

While Auburn is one of the largest and fastest-growing cities in Alabama by population, home insurance premiums remain in the average range for the state.

We utilized data submitted by the largest homeowners insurance providers in Alabama to compile the numbers for the average prices in Auburn. Then we whittled that list further to provide you premium estimates from the top insurers in Auburn. Let’s have a look at the average prices.

The rates in this article are sourced from the Alabama Department of Insurance, which provides real premiums from several companies in the state. These are average annual premiums for an HO-3 policy, which is the most common type of homeowners insurance plan.

Now, let’s take a look at the average premiums in the city, starting with houses valued at $150,000, and then $300,000, respectively. 

As you can see from the numbers above, the average price of premiums depends largely on the insurer. As insurers gain more policies in the state, they’re better able to mitigate risk and reduce the prices they charge to homeowners.

In the $150,000 house category, the most affordable carrier in Auburn is Allstate at $772 per year. Then comes Farmers at $1,082 and State Farm at $1,137 before the remaining carriers cross over the thousand-dollar mark. One prominent carrier that isn’t on the list is Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company, which has a large presence in Alabama and offers affordable rates as well.

Those numbers represent houses in Auburn that are worth $150,000 or have $150,000 worth of dwelling coverage, the value used to determine your home’s replacement cost. Let’s take a look at what you can expect to pay for $300,000 houses.

When looking at homeowners insurance premiums for $300,000 houses in Auburn, the most affordable insurers flip flop a bit, and only one company comes in near the $1,000 mark. Travelers takes the cake as the most affordable in this category at $1,060 per year.

The remaining insurers, including the ever-popular Alfa, one of the largest property insurers in the Heart of Dixie, have widely varying differences in pricing. The second-most affordable carrier is Allstate at $1,326, followed by Safeco at $1,990.

Every standard homeowners insurance policy, no matter where you’re located, comes with six different coverages. Each coverage is designed to protect something associated with your home, property or finances in a unique way. Let’s break them down.

The first coverage is dwelling, which protects the actual structure of your home. This coverage comes in two forms, replacement cost and market value.

Replacement cost coverage is the exact amount it would cost to rebuild your home, including all external features like a pool and outdoor kitchen, if it were entirely destroyed. Market value coverage incorporates the value of your home and property as it sat before the home was destroyed.

The second form of property protection is other structures coverage. It’s exactly what it sounds like. This coverage pays to repair or replace structures on your property that aren’t connected to your house. These are things like detached garages, carports and fences.

Its maximum coverage per claim is typically up to 10% of your dwelling value. So homeowners with $150,000 in dwelling coverage would have $15,000 in other structures coverage and homeowners with $300,000 in dwelling coverage would have $30,000 in other structures coverage.

Personal property coverage is next on the list. It’s designed to protect the personal belongings you keep inside your home and on your property. These are things like furniture, electronics, clothes and jewelry. You get to choose how much coverage you enroll in, so you’ll want the maximums to match the value of all your belongings combined.

The easiest way to determine the value of your belongings is to compile a home inventory of your contents. But keep in mind that high-value items like jewelry, art and collectibles have different coverage outlines than your other belongings. They’ll need to be scheduled in order to receive coverage for their total value.

If your house is damaged or destroyed and needs to be repaired or rebuilt, causing you to have to temporarily move out in the process, loss of use coverage can reimburse you for additional living expenses you incur while you’re forced out of your home. These are expenses like a rental home of equivalent value, storage fees for extra belongings and pet boarding for your furry family members.

Coverage E, the liability portion of your policy, kicks in if someone is injured on your property, your pet bites someone on or off your property, or if you accidentally damage someone else’s property. While policies typically come standard with at least $100,000 worth of coverage, policyholders get to determine the amount of coverage they need.

Many insurers offer up to $500,000 and some offer up to $1 million in coverage. However, crossing that threshold may require you to purchase additional insurance called an umbrella policy. Umbrella policies usually start at $1 million worth of coverage and can be added to in increments of $1 million.

The last piece of your coverage is medical payments coverage, which is similar to liability in retrospect. However, medical payments coverage only covers minor medical expenses for people injured on your property. But it doesn’t matter if you’re found liable.

Many different factors are at play when determining homeowners insurance prices. The most notable being the coverage maximums on your policy. The higher your maximums, the more your insurer will have to pay in the event of an unexpected peril. That also means you’ll pay more in premiums to offset the out-of-pocket risk taken on by your insurer.

The build of your home is also at the forefront of pricing. Homes made of masonry materials, such as brick and concrete, usually cost less to insure than homes made of wood. That’s because masonry materials are stronger than their wooden counterparts and better withstand heavy winds and other natural disasters.

Since Auburn is susceptible to tornadoes and even strong hurricane winds coming in from the Gulf of Mexico that haven’t quite subsided, factoring in the potential of wind damage to policy premiums is key for insurers.

Additionally, in late 2024 insurers will also provide coverage for catastrophic ground cover collapse, with the option of additional sinkhole coverage for those in areas susceptible to sinkholes.

Although the premiums represented in this article are a compilation of the city’s averages, there’s a chance you could pay less or more depending on your situation. While some of the top insurers in Auburn may have the lowest premiums on paper, you may successfully find that getting a policy from another insurer could be cheaper.

Allstate comes in at the lowest averages, costing an average of $772 for a $150,000 house and $1,326 for a $300,000 house. State Farm is $1,137 and more than double, $2,459 for the latter-priced house. Then comes Farmers at $1,082 and $2,680 and Alfa at $1,959 and $3,197.

Flood damage isn’t covered by homeowners insurance, so you’ll need a separate flood insurance policy to be covered from the costly perils caused by floods. Since they’re fairly common in Auburn, and extremely costly, securing a policy to protect your home is a great option.

Getting an affordable homeowners insurance policy in Auburn is quick and easy when you use Clovered. Simply enter a few details about your home in our online quoting tool, we’ll do all the hard work on the back end and then we’ll pair you with a policy that fits your needs and your budget.

We’re always here to help. If you’d rather speak to a licensed agent on the phone, just call 833-255-4117 Monday through Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 6 p.m. Or you can email us anytime at [email protected].